REVIEWS
Brittnay, downers grove IL, November 2021
This cookies are amazing! I first tried them at the Farmers Market when my mom was in town. She kept talking about them. She is visiting again and I had some delivered to Downers Grove tonight. I don’t know how they do it, but these cookies are like nothing I have ever tried!
kathleen, chicago il, september 2021
I was walking by at the Downers Grove (IL) farmers market and saw cookies. Ahh, yes. An easy choice. I must try the cookies. I picked out the Nutflix & Chill (classic chocolate chip + walnuts) and a s'mores cookie. OH MY WORD. Beyond expectation. I have since hunted them down to order them (this occasion happened Saturday, I have emailed them today). You will not be disappointed. So soft, balanced and truly just an AMAZING cookie. Well done.
Gabrielle, wheeling il, september 2021
Best cookies ever!! The fireside chats (s'mores) cookie heated in the microwave for 10 seconds was delicious.
rebecca, downers grove il, august 2021
I was lucky enough to purchase your cookies today! So delicious! Me & my daughter both said better than any Crumbl cookie!
mikey, toledo oh, july 2021
These cookies are absolutely INSANE! Thick, mushy inside, and delicious. I don't think I've eaten a heavier more delicious cookie in my life!
tania, mount prospect il, july 2021
I ordered the Fireside Chat (COTM) and it was DELICIOUS!!! I highly recommend Teddy's Cookies!
Sherry, chicago il, may 2021
These cookies are amazingggggg- I love how thick they are, because when warmed up they're so soft and melty. I highly recommend the full flight to try all the core flavors. I will definitely be re-ordering!
Eva, new york ny, may 2021
What can I say? The cookies are absolutely amazing. Every since I had my first bite, I kept coming back for more. I simply can’t stop ordering! I ordered it for my boyfriend’s family, and this is the only cookie his mom would finish. A nice warm cookie with a side of ice cream is my favorite after work dessert!
Tara, chicago il, april 2021
These cookies are amazing !! I’ve ordered three times now, and each time they are incredible. I especially love the March cookie of the month- I ate them for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. These cookies are meant to be shared but I definitely didn’t do that...
sasha, chicago il, april 2021
Brought home my order of Nutflix & Chill and left it on the counter. I came home a few hours later to find my husband, who does not like anything with nuts and definitely not anything with chocolate, devouring them! All he could say was, "Oh my god, what are these? You need to get more immediately, these are incredible!!!" Promptly placed another order! These cookies are truly incredible. Everything from unique flavor selections, excellent customer service to delivery and presentation is just top notch. Highly recommend!!
katie, los angeles, april 2021
Tastes amazing with every meal?? Extra efficient at creating serotonin in my brain Does the job for satisfying my occasional sweet tooth DE-CA-DENT You have follow the instructions on their lil card! Makes you feel like you got them fresh out of a bakery. Seriously, stockpile up!
JEN, new york ny, April 2021
Teddy's Cookies are DELICIOUS!! They are huge cookies that contain a copious amount of joy when you bite into them! It never fails to amaze me how creative and mouth watering the different monthly cookies are! It also ships very well across the country so they make great gifts for loved ones with a soft spot for sweets. Overall, 11/10 would recommend!
ELAN, CHICAGO IL, April 2021
I first ordered the Tall, Dark, and Doughy along with the cookie of the month at the time which was the lucky charms cookie (I hope they bring it back). When the next cookie of the month was announced I obviously had to try it. I highly recommend Teddy’s Cookies they are no joke the best cookies I have ever taken a bite into!!!
KAte, minneapolis mn, April 2021
Teddy’s Cookies are phenomenal. They’re the perfect sweet treat for any occasion that are sure to get you & your friends talking. They come up with fun monthly flavors that are a must try! You just HAVE to taste them for yourself!
ERIN, Los angeles ca, April 2021
I don't usually have a sweet tooth, unless there are Teddys Cookies involved. All of these flavors are incredible and I love how unique they are. The special flavors each month are also such a hit. And I have to note that they travel well -- definitely worth the wait for an incredible cookie!
peyton, chicago il, march 2021
When I think about a mouth watering, silky cookie I instantly think of Teddys Cookies. The immense amount of flavors that exist are incredible, from carrot cake to nutflix and chill. I mean, you can't really do better than a cream cheese filled carrot cake cookie. I don't know how they make their cookies GIGANTIC yet slightly doughey on the inside but I absolutely dig it. It's also awesome how they give you heating instructions on how to get that fresh out of the oven taste every order. If you want a sweet locally made treat, go for Teddys Cookies 🍪.
caroline, boston ma, march 2021
These have quickly become my favorite cookies - without a doubt! For me, I think the best part is the creativity of the company and how often they're coming up with new recipes that never fail to impress. The Cookie of the Month is something I genuinely look forward to and love to buy as gifts for my friends (...and myself) during tough times this past year. When it arrives in the mail, the product is always beautiful - the team does a great job at making a consistent and cute brand that makes you feel like you've sent yourself a gift basket of goodies. 10/10 I am a huge fan - would recommend to anyone who loves eating cookies or sending thoughtful gifts!
scott, st charles il, march 2021
Teddy's cookies are amazing! My favorite is in Berry Good Company. The cookies never last long in our house. I suggest you start with a full flight. Once you try them you'll be a life time customer. Check back often for the cookie of the month.
Alexis, austin tx, march 2021
There’s only one word to describe these cookies....LIFE-CHANGING! Once you go Teddy’s Cookies you never go back. These are hands-down the world’s best cookies. Heavenly! The gorgeous packaging also makes for a great gift!!
rony, tampa fl, march 2021
Love these cookies! They stay delicious even after being delivered across the country. The size is perfect for splitting with a special someone.
alina, chicago il, february 2021
Teddy's Cookies, where do I even begin?! I was a bit skeptical at first to buy a cookie online but I was completely convinced after trying these. They are unlike any homemade cookies I've ever had. You'll be impressed by the amazing flavor combinations and quality ingredients in every bite. I am a fan of all their cookies but I especially look forward to their cookie of the month (COTM). I've ordered cookies for myself and others. I highly recommend giving these a try!
JOSH, washington dc, february 2021
First, these cookies are incredible. The perfect prescription for those days that are just too long. Second, the customer service does not get better. The teddys cookies team stays in touch throughout the whole process, does an amazing job of ensuring the cookies still look good when shipped, and they're just over all incredibly helpful. Highly recommend.